|
Small is Beautiful And Economical! And easy to run! And it's called
the REVA. The REVA Electric Car has finally arrived and though for
quite some time it seemed that the car was much ahead of its times,
the OVERDRIVE road test puts all such notions to rest. The car was
put through a week of grueling test routine in Pune and not only
had the midget impressed all of us at editorial office but drew
up a sizeable following amongst the common folk of Pune. In my over
four years with OVERDRIVE, I have driven many cars, some before
anyone from the public has even heard about them, some costing close
to a crore of rupees and others which are huge, stylish and attractive
While most cars draw a lot of attention and have people asking
you about its price, fuel efficiency and the like, others like the
expensive Mercs draw only gazes of silent admiration. If it weren't
for the fact that this is the road test of the Eva Electric car,
I would have bet that you would not have been able to guess which
car drew the most crowds…yes, even more than the Mercedes-Benz SLK
or the mammoth Yamaha V-Max motorcycle.
It was exhilarating to witness the car getting so many people
excited and interested. The most often asked questions being whether
the car was imported. What is its name? Does it run on electricity?
What is the body made of? How much distance did it cover in one
charge? And how much it cost? One evening after office the editor
wanted to go for a drive in the REVA and I drove behind him in his
Merc.
On getting to his place I found it difficult to wade through the
questions that everyone seemed to ask about the REVA and I very
quietly exchanged keys and made my getaway. I must remember to ask
him for how long he was answering questions about the REVA! The
next day he himself acknowledged that the REVA was second to none
in its crowd pulling abilities.
DESIGN & STYLE: As cute as it gets! Surprisingly everyone commented
on how cute the REVA was. As I drove into my apartment complex a
group of young girls burst out in unison: "HOW CU-U-TE" And as I
parked the car and started making arrangements for replenishing
its power pack, I got to talk to people I had never met before in
the four years that I have stayed at that place. Everyone agreed
that the car was very cute without doubt.
Some macho men however begged to differ, calling it frog-faced!
Yes, though the styling might be oddball, the REVA's appeal comes
from its size, the bright colours and the shimmering graphics, and
fits the exact dictionary definition of cute to the "e". The overall
build quality is good though there are a lot of small niggles that
still need to be sorted out. The adjustment of the latch on the
rear hatch for example, gave us some problems.
CHASIS & SUSPENSION: Rear suspension requires some more work. With
initial inputs from a team of the of the Pasadena Design Centre
in the US, the complete design work including 3D-modelling of all
the assemblies and all the individual parts, analysis of the entire
chassis has all been done in-house by REVA Design Engineers with
assistance from the Parametric Technology Corporation.
The body of the REVA is made up of a tubular steel space frame
which has advantages of a hindrance free and high interior space-exterior
volume ratio, high structural rigidity besides forming a very effective
energy absorbing shell for occupant protection during crashes.
The body panels are made of ABS, which not only make the car lightweight
but are also energy absorbing and have the ability of absorbing
impacts without breaking or deforming. The suspension features Mac
Pherson struts up front with an anti-roll bar and is on par with
most small cars. The rear however uses a pan hard rod with coils
over dampers. With the power train housed on the rear axle and the
need to maintain high pressures in the tyres to minimize rolling
friction, the suspension comes across as being rather too stiff.
Bad roads cause the rear to jump and shift besides being harsh on
the passengers as well as the body of the car.
ENGINE & TRANSMISSION: Cutting edge EV technology. The integrated
power supply and drive system consists of a high torque (69Nm),
5kW (6.4bhp) continuous and 13kW (18bhp) peak output DC motor mounted
at the rear axle. A microprocessor-based controller regulates the
delivery of current to the motor and ensures smooth acceleration
and precise speeds based on the position of the accelerator. The
motor controller also helps the car to be driven in three modes
- forward, economy and reverse.
Apart from these functions the motor controller also does regenerative
braking and recharges the power pack through the motor when braking.
The motor controller also keeps a thermal check on both the motor
and itself to prevent it from overheating. It also constantly updates
the EMS (Energy management system) on its functioning. The intelligent
EMS is a computerized system that is the hub of all electrical activity.
It continuously interfaces with all the electric systems in the
car, monitors them and informs the user through telltale lights
on the instrument panel.
In case of the charge on the power pack running low, the EMS limits
the drawing of energy from the power pack, thereby maximizing range.
It monitors the charging process, the state of the charge as well
as the level of water in the batteries which can be replenished
through a centralized feeder port at the edge of the charging bay.
The power pack itself consists of eight 6-volt tubular EV lead batteries,
which also carry a three-year or 40,000km warranty. Here lies the
biggest challenge for EV manufacturers. The battery pack to run
to run a car even of the size of the REVA becomes quite large and
heavy and is one of the main contributors in taking the weight of
the car up to as high as 640kg. The REVA Electric Car Co like most
other Ev companies around the world is working with another Indian
company on developing lightweight Lithium-ion batteries for use
in EV's.
Though the cost of these batteries might be appreciably more, the
range and the efficiency of the EV will increase while the time
taken for charging will go down. It currently takes about five hours
to fully charge the lead-acid battery pack and two and a half hours
can change the power pack to 80 per cent capacity. The power from
the motor is transmitted to the rear wheels undergoing a single
seven-to-one reduction on its way to the rear wheels.
Thus the REVA is one of the very few rear-wheel drive cars available
in the country today. Everything seems to have been thought of and
taken care of. The whine from the motor which was quite evident
when we had first driven the car seems to have been an electric
car, it comes as quite a surprise when the car moves off noiselessly,
both for the driver as well as bystanders.
|
PERFORMANCE: Nothing electrifying but adequate for city driving.
There are two forward modes to choose from with one (E) limiting
top speed and acceleration to maximize range while the other (F)
maximizes performance at the cost of range. It is easy to switch
from one to the other and while most of the driving can be done
with the selector on E, one can shift to F when the need arises
or the situation warrants.
Even in the F mode the acceleration is not all that great and it
takes as much time for the REVA to reach 30kmph as it takes a fuel
injected Maruti 800 to reach 60kmph. The 50kmph mark comes up in
17.14 seconds in the quicker mode and if you are headed for a long
day in the city and are switched on to the E mode, 50kmph will come
up in over 24 seconds. Top speed is claimed to be limited to 65kmph
in the F mode and to 55kmph in the E mode, but with two people onboard
along with the testing equipment, the car could only get up to just
over 55kmph in the F mode.
This is not meant to be a performance-oriented car and it delivers
sufficiently when and where it matters. With its limited range it
is doubtful whether the car will ever leave city limits and for
driving in cities like Pune, its performance is more than adequate.
It never lags behind the pace of the city traffic and is capable
of a decant amount of overtaking too. Besides it does not fall behind
when starting off at traffic lights. If you manage to get onto the
front row at a red traffic light, you will more often than not be
the first across and can look forward to an empty road ahead.
RANGE: Adequate for intra-city driving! Might be problematic for
metros or larger cities! While the claimed range on a full charge
is up to 80km in the F mode and up to 100km in the E mode, in our
experience of city driving with the music system playing, the REVA
comes to the end of its tether at 72km. This sort of range is quite
adequate for a single stretch of driving in the not so large cities
like Pune and Bangalore but might turn out to be problematic for
larger metros like Delhi. Even then I do not think that there are
single stretches of more than 70-odd kilometers but going shopping
or even going to the office and then getting back home might definitely
entail drives of more than 70km. Going to the office might not be
a problem as the car could be put on charge there but the other
kind of trips might pose some problems. The manufacturer has come
up with a solution to that by installing charging points at major
commercial districts of the towns where the car has been launched.
So while there were no such charging outlets in Pune, I have seen
a few around the major markets of Bangalore.
ECONOMY: Much cheaper to run and maintain. One full charge of the
battery-pack uses up nine units of electricity, which translates
into 40 paise per kilometer. This compares very favourably to the
running cost of a small gasoline engine car at over Rs. 2 for every
kilometer. The only major cost incurred on the REVA would be the
tyres, the cost of changing of which would be nearly the same as
on normal fossil-fuel cars. The REVA, on the other hand would not
need periodic changes of various filters, lubricating oils etc and
the other major cost would be the changing of the battery pack after
three years or 40,000km. The battery pack would cost between Rs
30,000 and Rs 40,000 and this would translate into a maximum cost
of a rupee per kilometer run. Even if we include this cost into
the running costs of this electric vehicle, at Rs 1.40 per kilometer
it is still substantially cheaper to run than internal combustion
engine cars. And we aren't even including all the other maintenance
costs incurred on petrol / diesel-powered cars. All this works fine
if there are only a maximum of two people traveling in your car.
Once you take into consideration the fact that any small car can
seat four fully grown adults and is used with a full compliment
of passengers, then all the cost is divided by four to give a per
person estimate, while the costs per person for the REVA are achieved
by dividing the costs of running the car by a factor of two only.
Besides, many states offer incentives like sales tax waivers or
road tax subsidies on the purchase of EV's while corporates can
claim full 100 per cent depreciation during the first year itself.
EQUIPMENT: An electric car with air con and a music system and…
The Standard REVA that we had on test comes with just a 4-speed
blower and a Kenwood music system. But RECC has just recently launched
two other variants of the car, which also feature air conditioning.
The REVA AC is available at an introductory ex-showroom price just
about Rs 25,000 more than the standard REVA. The top-of-the-line
variant, Classe, features an air con with remote facility (the air
con can be switched on even while you are still away from the car
and the car is already cool by the time you get to it), leather
upholstery, central locking, trendy decals, a high end Kenwood stereo
system, Auto cop security system, special wheel caps and door trims,
antiglare and body coloured rear view mirrors and is available for
an introductory price of Rs 3.18 lakh (ex-showroom Delhi). A cabriolet
version is on its way.
SUMMING IT UP Thus the REVA makes sense for people who travel
alone with two people in the car, and that alone or with two people
in the car, and that too for stretches of not more than 70-odd kilometers
before getting to a place where the car is parked for at least a
couple of hours.
Yes, it makes sense for a lot of people, like working wives for
example, who use their cars everyday for getting to the office where
the car can be put on charge for most of the day and then maybe
a few shopping trips over the week to the nearby grocery store or
supermarket. For longer trips or holidays they usually travel with
their family and take their husband's car, which is in any way bigger.
Well, it could be the other way around too. So the REVA makes for
an ideal second car for a small family or for grown up children
who are still studying and whose parents can afford to buy them
a car and would prefer the REVA because it is simple to drive and
does not open up too many more possibilities.
Companies can buy it for their staff members who have to travel
short distances for work or inside huge plants and factories. It
also makes sense for people living on university campuses or cantonment
areas which are self sufficient townships by themselves and work,
home, shopping, friends, clubs and theatres are all within a 10km
radius. And this zero-emission car is also the perfect vehicle for
people with a conscience!
- Yogendra Pratap
|